Yog vim li cas Harry Potter conjured tam sim no tsis pom kev siv ib tug khawv koob wand?

Nyob rau hauv lub fairy taleas ntiaj teb no fantasy epic Dzhoan Rouling khawv koob cia omnipotent. Txawm hais tias tsis nkaus ntshiab yog vim li cas lub Harry Potter conjured ib tug zoo lub zeem muag, nws yog tseeb hais tias cov khawv koob ntawm wizards muab hwj chim tshaj txhua yam. Siv ib tug wand yuav levitate khoom nyob rau hauv ib tug duel sib ntaus, enslaving thiab txawm tua; siv lawv txoj kev potions yuav poob rau hauv kev hlub nrog rau lwm cov, ntse ua txuj mus yuav tuag txawm sim lwm tsos. Muaj ntau miraculous hwj chim thiab muaj tus nto moo artifacts: lub legendary deathly Hallows, yog dhau los ntawm tiam mus rau tiam enchanted Marauder lub daim ntawv qhia thiab Arturom Uizli tsheb "Ford Anglia".

Cuaj kaum, ntau nyeem thiab viewers muaj yog ib tug tsim nyog lo lus nug: "Yog hais tias cov khawv koob ntawm ib tug fairy taleas yog li ntawd omnipotent, yog hais tias nws yuav raug tej lub hom phiaj, yog vim li cas tsis Harry Potter conjured ib lub zeem muag ntawm nws tus kheej kom tshem tawm thaum kawg lub tsom iav?" Muaj peb hypotheses, muab lwm cov lus teb rau lo lus nug burning.

tej yam ntuj tso kev cai lij choj

Nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, tus thawj thiab feem ntau plausible teb pom tias nws tus kheej Dzhoan Rouling ncaj qha nyob rau hauv lub cuab ntxhiab. Yog hais tias ib tug kiv cua ntawm cov dab neeg hais txog cov tub-Leej twg-Nyob wondering dab tsi Harry Potter conjured ib lub zeem muag ntawm nws tus kheej, cia nws hais nws tus kheej tib cov lus nug. Yog vim li cas yog Dzheyms Potter , dhau lawm, coj qhws tsom iav? Yog vim li cas tsis muaj leej twg ntawm lub cim (tshwj xeeb tshaj yog cov ntxhais) nyob rau hauv tsis muaj txoj kev zoo tuaj cov tsos nws tus kheej nrog kev pab los ntawm cov khawv koob? Tom qab tag nrho, nws yuav zoo li, lawv twb muaj tag nrho cov kev pab tsim nyog: khawv koob hwj chim, khawv koob Wands, dissatisfaction nrog tsos los yog cov neeg pluag pom.

Lub attentive nyeem ntawv yuav tam sim ntawd cam: yog vim li cas yog tsis muaj ib tug tam sim no zoo tsos? Thiab yog dab tsi yog qhov zoo tshaj tus phooj ywg Harry - Germiona Greyndzher?

Tseeb, yog vim li cas tsis Harry Potter conjured li ib lub zeem muag ntawm kuv tus kheej, yog hais tias nws muaj peev xwm siv khawv koob thiab kom lub excessively ntev pem hauv ntej hniav?

Heev tsuas, lub wizard yuav tsum zoo li xwm tau muab. Txawm Hermione twb txwv tsis pub ua dab tsi nrog cov hniav - tsis tsuas magicians, tab sis nws niam thiab txiv yog Muggles-ua hauj lwm cov kws kho hniav. Nws yog heev txaus ntshai rau cuam tshuam nrog yam tseem ceeb predetermined los ntawm qhov. Cov phau ntawv pheej hais tias nws yog tsis yooj yim sua kom hloov dab tsi ruaj nyob rau hauv lawv cov tsos. Thaj, mus rau lub hauj lwm ntawm cov kev txiav txim hauv nruab nrog cev kuj muaj tseeb.

tsis muaj peev xwm

Txawm tias cov khawv koob zoo li omnipotent, Yog hais tias qhov no yog tiag tiag rau hauv cov ntaub ntawv? Yog vim li cas Harry Potter conjured ib lub zeem muag ntawm nws tus kheej, nyob rau hauv kev phem ntawm lub kev txwv ntawm cov laus thiab wiser wizards? Nws yog tau hais tias xws li ib tug haib nyhuv ntawm tej yam yees siv fais fab nyob rau hauv kev muaj tiag yog overrated; Tsis pom qhov twg nyob rau hauv cov thawj qhov chaw nws tsis yog hais tias nws yog ua tau los txhawb qhov txhia tej spell los yog potion li ntawd tej yam uas tshwm sim yog fwm rau ib tug lub neej. Siv ib ntus no thiab potions seeb thiab tej zaum pointless; yog vim li cas rov qab ua dua dua tib ritual, Yog hais tias koj muaj peev xwm cia li so coj tsom-iav, raws li ua lub Muggles?

Ib tug heev ib feem ntawm cov ua cim

Yog lwm hypothesis, teb cov lus nug hais txog yog vim li cas Harry Potter conjured tam sim no tsis pom kev. Ntsiab lus - qhov no yog ib qho tseem ceeb feem ntawm cov duab ntawm lub protagonist. Nws tsis yog ib tug botanist thiab zauchka, tab sis nws cov ntsiab lus muab me ntsis kaum ib xyoos - cov thawj cim ntawm cov phau ntawv thiab cov zaj duab xis - lub feem ntawm kev ruaj khov thiab insecurity uas ua rau nws tsis kam mus empathize, txawm tsis paub txog tag nrho cov kev tshwm sim ntawm nws lub neej. Germiona Greyndzher thawj tuav Harry Potter thiab Rona Uizli koj lub siab cia li thaum cam khwb cia hnoos li no "reparative" nyob rau hauv lub tsheb ciav hlau "Hogwarts Express" thiab mends tawg Shackle ntsiab lus Harry nyob ua ke nrog daim kab xev. Nyob rau hauv lub kawg, Harry txiv, dhau lawm, coj qhws tsom iav; no kom meej, nyob rau hauv ib tes, nyob rau hauv ntau nrog cov me nyuam ntsuag tshwm nyob rau hauv cov zaj duab xis cov dab ntawm James, thiab nyob rau lwm yam - ua Severus Snape xav saib tsis taus Harry lub resemblance rau nws tus txiv.

Yog li, cov neeg pluag lub zeem muag ntawm cov ua cim - tsis yog li ntawd illogical meej, raws li tej zaum nws yuav zoo li thaum xub thawj siab ib muag. Revisit koj nyiam films; Yog Harry Potter yog tau tsis tau tsom iav - ob leeg nrog thiab tsis muaj ib tug caws pliav nyob rau hauv daim ntawv ntawm cov xob laim rau nws lub hauv pliaj ..?